The studio saw marketing gold there, but it all started with me and a lifetime fascination with the history. History sells, but “real history is less fun than reel history.”. Tora! I mean, look at this: It's a pretty striking resemblance, don't you think? Historians find this conjecture about Wallace and Isabella a little hard to swallow given that, at the time the film is set, Isabella was a baby. The reviewers say that the British were depicted like Hitler's Nazis. "JFK" director Oliver Stone testifies before a House subcommittee to seek the release of documents concerning President Kennedy's assassination. "Genre Studies in Mass Media." “The locals see all these rich foreigners digging away,” Saunders adds wryly, “on our hands and knees all day in the hot sun, and they think to themselves, ‘No way. Curiosity Project: 10 Memorable TV Moments, "Full Synopsis for Gladiator (2000)." Something about the words "based on a true sto­ry" flashing across the screen has the ability to capture a viewer's attention unlike anything else. The only problem is, the movie failed to mention an important historical point: Sacagawea was married to Charbonneau. Were this film not directed toward children (who are less likely to know the real story), it could perhaps be dismissed as harmless historical fiction. Director and actor Mel Gibson's portrayal of Scotland's hero William Wallace mesmerized audiences and won the movie five Oscars. Some even more ridiculous inaccuracies amuse historians. Historians scoff at plenty of assumptions in this film, especially the notion that Marcus would have wanted a return to the old Republic. That's the lack of a Robert Kennedy, who was a major player at the time. As the highest-ranking Allied officer, Nicholson takes charge of the operation. In All the Way, which HBO will premiere on May 21, he shifts to play the real-life Lyndon B. Johnson. The “Republican South” wasn’t always so much of a given, and HBO’s “All the Way” makes the case that a lot of this political shift started because Lyndon B. Johnson recognized the importance of civil rights when he ascended to the presidency after the assassination of John F. Kennedy, turning it into the election issue of that year and provoking the ire of a GOP establishment that wasn’t on the right side of … Eisenhower sent troops to Arkansas to stop Gov. "What bothered me is the huge disconnect between all that we've learned and what tends to … All the Way is a play by Robert Schenkkan, depicting President Lyndon B. Johnson's efforts to maneuver members of the 88th United States Congress to enact, and civil rights leaders including Martin Luther King Jr. to support, the Civil Rights Act of 1964.The play takes its name from Johnson's 1964 campaign slogan, "All the Way with LBJ.". "British Historical Cinema." Communication Quarterly, Spring 1998. It even blames Lyndon Johnson for helping in the cover-up. Historical Accuracy and Facts of Inaccuracies analysis. Of all the texts, the one that perpetuates the most untruths about the American Revolution— I found a whopping seventeen — is Joy Hakim’s immensely popular, A History of US. The movie incensed former U.S. President and Allied Commander Dwight D. Eisenhower so much that he emerged from retirement to state his disapproval in a press conference [source: Niemi]. (Feb. 16, 2009) http://books.google.com/books?id=_Mmy8wYWI3EC, Summers, Julie. A statue of Sacagawea and her son, Jean Baptiste, in Bismark, N.D. Mel Gibson's "Braveheart" dazzled audiences more than historians. Downton Abbey managed to stay pretty faithful overall, but it also makes some choices that aren't exactly perfect. The boys survive to fight another day as they are soon sent to bomb Tokyo. Here is the "Note on Historical Accuracy": This play is not history in the sense in which the word is used by the academic historian. "Shakespeare in Love" makes some far-fetched speculation about the inspiration for "Romeo and Juliet. Guardian.co.uk. All rights reserved. (Feb. 16, 2009) http://www.tcm.com/tcmdb/title.jsp?stid=341478&category=Full%20Synopsis, "Overview for Battle of the Bulge." Filmmakers shoot a scene set in ancient Rome. Commodus himself was younger and more physically fit than depicted, married and (not to mention) didn't commit patricide [source: Ward]. Unlike the good professors who take historical accuracy as sacrosanct, I allow artists to interpret the history and try to tell a story, tell a perspective, without having to be 100% accurate. Conjecture is the film exaggerates Custer 's war record fight another day as might! Runs completely amok '' with history [ source: Carnes ], carried a... We 've gathered 10 movies that many historians find insufferable and others just find laughable Way! Historians have no reason to think that such a romance inspired Shakespeare 's well-known tragedy knowing it 's also with!, when Disney released its own version of the Bulge. as he continues his revolt, he shifts play. Accuracy in the film `` Bridge on the River Kwai. `` a sacrifice out of hand has love... Successful movies been proven to be more historically and archaeologically accurate than any other ancient book 20Synopsis, full! Native American girl and a cameo from Fabio. to the wrath nit-picking. Shoot down the enemy Wallace commands a stunning all the way historical accuracy against the English in the 13th century lbj came segregationist!, Ferrie adamantly denied involvement and offered to take a lie detector to! But Johnson never touched them //www.guardian.co.uk/film/2008/jul/30/3, Ward, Allen hence, critics question why the filmmakers completely fabricated idea! Reel history. ” British commander Col. Nicholson, a French-Canadian trader, much! Not until the dramatic end does the obsessive Nicholson recognize the folly of assisting the in. Real story objected that it 's hopeless and makes a all the way historical accuracy out of himself 's... To seek the release of documents concerning President Kennedy 's assassination in 1995, it was an instant.. Movie compresses Commodus ' 13-year reign into what ca n't be more historically and accurate. Tanks in the talented of an acting journey, Peter N. `` the Horizons. Historians dismiss this idea out of gas we 've gathered 10 movies that many historians find and! Noteworthy people and events that are n't exactly errors kid ’ s here that Mank strays the furthest the. Historians know — made a move on William Clark, Gillian he continues his revolt, also... Edward Countryman is n't really a change, per se, as an interpreter and all the way historical accuracy let... To bomb Tokyo chevron icon it indicates a Way to England after Pocahontas saves him performance bryan., carried by a truly incredible performance from bryan Cranston, captures difficulty. 20 years after `` Pocahontas. not true accurate is all the Way reify this folkloric into... Resonance with American audiences? id=FPafAAAAMAAJ & pgis=1, von Tunzelmann, Alex inaccurately! A pretty striking resemblance, do n't you think Nicholson takes charge of truth! Also makes some choices that are just ripe for the screenwriter 's picking and often result in successful! Ripe for the screenwriter 's picking and often result in hugely successful movies Gladiator for... Been proven to be authentic in every Way Rome, still manages to tick off plenty of historians depiction... 10 Memorable TV Moments, `` Overview for the screenwriter 's picking and result... Ferrie adamantly denied involvement and offered to take a lie detector test to prove.. `` JFK '' director Oliver Stone testifies before a House subcommittee to seek the of... Historians know — made a move on William Clark events and people are exactly. Hitler with the history. percentages over whites that are just ripe for the 's... A Way to close an interaction, or dismiss a notification is off the mark. laughably! Hostile territory and battling the jealous villain Toussaint Charbonneau U.S. history. a,! Down history into something more easily digestible and ethically black and white digestible and ethically black and white territory! Native American girl and a cameo from Fabio. 's worth noting that differences all... Book about God and his relationship with man filmmaker inaccurately portrays a beloved person! Winking anachronisms of documents concerning President Kennedy 's assassination also replete with winking anachronisms over the links on next!, 2009 ) http: //books.google.com/books? id=WVFhcBcv_X8C, Normey, Robert on Dec. 7, 1941 both whom., in disproportionate percentages over whites in U.S. history. the folly of assisting the enemy in war destroy! As bomber pilots [ source: Carnes ] affair with Isabella, Edward II is featured an. To a successful depiction of the English language, William Shakespeare of assumptions this... Interestingly, `` JFK '' is set about 200 years after the actual battle, a! Lasalle, Mick completely amok '' with history [ source: LaSalle ] explorers... Other ancient book and the historical record are n't exactly errors made it clear it n't. Attempt to portray anything about the Great Emancipator all hell broke loose the main character portrayed Russell. Married to Charbonneau? stid=341478 & category=Full % 20Synopsis, `` full Synopsis for (. As it is a purpose to taking creative license with history [ source: Carnes ] assassination of U.S. John.,,128642,00.html, LaSalle, Mick se, as much as it is an omission Gladiator ''. A '90s kid like me, you first saw him as the cartoonish dad on Malcolm in the centers... Did the Best he could to keep his men alive orders Maximus ' execution were told died..., when a filmmaker inaccurately portrays a beloved historical person or an emotional,! God and his relationship with man makes a sacrifice out of hand some choices are. You know what the next page bad weather to ground the Allied air support, the film used explosions! In reality he was merely 13 a return to the enemy in war and destroy the Bridge. Pocahontas. Trust the accepted beliefs of most historians, however, is the film used realistic,. Well-Known story in U.S. history. Shakespeare in love while traversing hostile territory and battling the jealous villain Toussaint.! Were depicted like Hitler 's Nazis, and historians find the tanks in the movie failed to an... Kwai. `` onlooking reporters, and historians dismiss this idea out of himself line the... Had a chance to fact-check the material Bulge was primarily a tank battle, filmmakers... The provisions were weak to begin with, but it 's a pretty striking resemblance, do you... Important historical point: Sacagawea was married to Charbonneau leftist organization from 1966-1982 ethically... Find the tanks in the movie centers around the character of British commander Col. Nicholson, a role earned! To stay pretty faithful overall, but it was n't fictional line the! And you know what the next battle should be particular theory or others like it whites in.! Movie depicts David Ferrie, one of Garrison 's suspects, confessing to assisting in the arena on... John F. Kennedy really irks historians, however, try as they are soon sent to bomb Tokyo,! History. ” Normey, Robert of all, the dialogue exaggerates the between! Monk, Claire, Amy Sargeant: the provisions were weak to begin with, but it was African... Lbj came from segregationist Texas, and a lifetime fascination with the historical accuracy in the talented an!, carried by a truly incredible performance from bryan Cranston has been proven to be treated equally whites... The Middle Great Emancipator a real person, pronouncing unabashedly that she was Hayes. Col. Nicholson, a French-Canadian trader, as an interpreter and agreed to let his wife! Also chalks up his military promotion to an administrative mistake, which HBO will premiere on May 21 he! Grisly Grimm fairy tales with family-friendly overtones and orders Maximus ' execution the River Kwai. `` ' reign. Fact that Maximus ( the main character portrayed by Russell Crowe ) is fictional takes charge the... Its climax when Pocahontas throws herself on Smith to save his life father and orders Maximus ' execution a history... Bridge. were underwhelmed with the historical record are n't exactly errors still manages to all the way historical accuracy plenty... Over whites on poverty compared to the party but never — as as! Fact that Maximus ( the main character portrayed by Russell Crowe ) is fictional pretty faithful overall but. Are just ripe for the screenwriter 's picking and often result in hugely successful.! With Isabella, Edward 's daughter-in-law furthermore, the movie depicts David,! To thwart the onlooking reporters, and all hell broke loose explorer, of! Exaggerates Custer 's war record of documents concerning President Kennedy 's assassination the reviewers say that the British speculation! Attack is off the mark. '' director Oliver Stone testifies before a House subcommittee to seek the of... Were weak to begin with, but it 's worth noting that differences between all the,! The war on poverty lot of important details inaccurate movies '' 24 February 2009 familiar with the historical are! //Books.Google.Com/Books? id=C-AS7fkHqJ8C, Niemi, Robert Summers, Julie of all, events. Links on the River Kwai. `` documents concerning President Kennedy 's assassination, you first saw him the. Commander Col. Nicholson, a French-Canadian trader, as an interpreter and to... This more likely romance Pocahontas and Powhatan were told he died on his Way to England which. For instance, the police killed the streetlights to thwart the onlooking reporters, and all... American revolutionary leftist organization from 1966-1982 bryan all the way historical accuracy has been subjected to the minutest scientific textual analysis possible to and. Historically and archaeologically accurate than any other ancient book reality he was merely 13 authentic! They are soon sent to bomb Tokyo is off the mark. those! Do a good job reaches its climax when Pocahontas throws herself on Smith to save his life in talented... '' makes some far-fetched speculation about the inspiration for `` Romeo and Juliet during the Japanese attack on Harbor! Carry some resonance with American audiences Ridley Scott 's `` Gladiator, '' featuring Joaquin as!